SEC Wants Lawyers to Become Whistle Blowers
January 9, 2003
A majority of commissioners at the Securities and Exchange Commission favors adopting a regulation that would require lawyers to blow the whistle on client who misbehave. Lawyers fear adoption of the rule would change the nature of the entire attorney-client relationship.
- Specifically, the rule would require a lawyer who believes he sees evidence of a client committing a "material" securities-law violation -- and is unable to get the company's board to stop it -- to quit and inform the SEC that he is quitting for "professional considerations."
- The so-called "noisy withdrawal" requirement can be traced to a Congressional directive contained in last year's Sarbanes-Oxley Act -- which called for stricter rules to enforce corporate governance.
- Congress called upon the SEC to adopt rules "setting forth minimum standards of professional conduct for attorneys" practicing before the commission -- and recommended that outside and company lawyers be required to report "evidence of a material violation" of securities laws "up the ladder" to senior executives or a company's board.
- Lawyers complain the rule would make them into regulators and would constitute a dramatic breach of confidentiality.
One alternative under consideration is to require companies themselves to inform the SEC when an outside lawyer has quit.
Source: Mitchell Pacelle and Michael Schroeder, "New SEC Rule Could Turn Lawyers Into Whistle Blowers," Wall Street Journal, January 9, 2003.
For text (WSJ subscription required)
Browse more articles on Government Issues