Given Land Titles, Squatters Do More Work
January 9, 2003
An estimated 400 to 600 million people worldwide are squatters, living on land to which they have no title, usually on the outskirts of cities. Peruvian economist Hernando de Soto has shown that the growth of squatting was due to legal systems that made it very expensive and took years to title and transfer property. He persuaded Peru to undertake to what has become the world's largest titling program.
- From 1995 to 2001, more than 1.2 million households -- 6.3 million people -- received title to the properties they were inhabiting.
- Before the reforms, it could take years for squatters to obtain a title; the reforms enabled squatters to get titles quickly for a fee of $20 to $50.
In addition to turning land into transferable capital, titling may have other economic benefits. Princeton University economics student Erica Field asked whether the former squatters increased their labor output as a result. The theory is that those without titles must remain at their properties to protect them from intruders, while residents with legal title are freed up to pursue work in the community.
- Field found labor supply increased as a result of land titling.
- Two to three years after titling came to a neighborhood, families that were in untitled houses before the reform worked 20 more hours a week, on average, than those from untitled houses in neighborhoods that had not yet had title reform.
- By contrast, among households titled before the reforms, family work hours were a statistically insignificant four hours greater in areas where reform was introduced early then in those where it was yet to be introduced.
Interestingly, although the overall hours worked increased, the amount of labor supplied by children was 27 percent lower for families that were initially squatting in neighborhoods that introduced title reform early.
Source: Alan B. Krueger (Princeton University), "Economic Scene: A Study Looks at Squatters and Land Titles in Peru," New York Times, January 9, 2003; based on Erica Field, "Entitled to Work: Urban Property Rights and Labor Supply in Peru" Working Paper No. 469, Princeton University, Industrial Relations Section, October 2002
For NYT text
Browse more articles on International Issues