The Limits of Wind Power

October 11, 2012

Environmentalists advocate wind power as one of the main alternatives to fossil fuels, claiming that it is both cost effective and low in carbon emissions. A new study by William J. Korchinski and Julian Morris of the Reason Foundation seeks to evaluate these claims.

  • Existing estimates of the life-cycle emissions from wind turbines range from 5 to 100 grams (g) of carbon dioxide (CO2) equivalent per kilowatt hour (kWh) of electricity produced.
  • This very wide range is explained by differences in what was included in each analysis, and the proportion of electricity generated by wind.

Wind blows at speeds that vary considerably, leading to wide variations in power output. To address this variability, power supply companies must install backup capacity, which kicks in when demand exceeds supply from the wind turbines. The need for this backup capacity significantly increases the cost of producing power from wind. Since backup power in most cases comes from fossil fuel generators, this effectively limits the carbon-reducing potential of new wind capacity.

The extent to which CO2 emissions can be reduced by using wind power ultimately depends on the specific characteristics of an existing power grid and the amount of additional wind-induced variability risk the grid operator will tolerate.

  • A conservative grid operator can achieve CO2 emissions reduction via increased wind power of approximately 18g of CO2 equivalent/kWh, or about 3.6 percent of total emissions from electricity generation.
  • The analysis reported in this study indicates that 20 percent would be the extreme upper limit for wind penetration.
  • At this level the CO2 emissions reduction is 90g of CO2 equivalent/kWh, or about 18 percent of total emissions from electricity generation.
  • Using wind to reduce CO2 to this level costs $150 per metric ton (i.e. 1,000 kilograms, or 2,200 lbs) of CO2 reduced.

Very high wind penetrations are not achievable in practice due to the increased need for power storage, the decrease in grid reliability and the increased operating costs. Given these constraints, this study concludes that a more practical upper limit for wind penetration is 10 percent. At 10 percent wind penetration, the CO2 emissions reduction due to wind is approximately 45g CO2 equivalent/kWh, or about 9 percent of total.

Source: William J. Korchinski and Julian Morris, "The Limits of Wind Power," Reason Foundation, October 4, 2012.

 

Browse more articles on Environment Issues