NCPA - National Center for Policy Analysis


February 5, 2010

Since President Barack Obama was sworn into office, the U.S.  economy has shed 3.4 million jobs and the unemployment rate has risen to 10 percent.  But not all sectors of the economy have been suffering equally.  In fact, the sector of the economy most supportive of President Obama has not only avoided contraction, but has actually managed to grow instead, says Conn Carroll, Assistant Director for the Heritage Foundation's Strategic Communications. 

According to a recent report released by the Bureau of Labor Statistics (BLS): 

  • In 2009 the number of federal, state and local government employees represented by unions actually rose by 64,000.
  • Coupled with union losses in the private sector economy, 2009 became the first year in American history that a majority of American union members work for the government.
  • Specifically, 52 percent of all union members now work for the federal, state or local government, up from 49 percent in 2008.
  • To better illustrate these statistics: three times more union members work in the Post Office than in the auto industry. 

So why should Americans care, asks Carroll?  There's one simple reason: private firms face competition; governments don't.  If a union extracts a contract from a private firm that eats up too much of the profits, then that firm will be unable to reinvest those profits and will lose out to competitors.  But when a union extracts a generous contract from a government, the answer is always higher taxes or borrowing to pay for the bloated spending: 

  • The average worker for a state or local government earns $39.83 an hour in wages and benefits compared to $27.49 an hour in the private sector.
  • While over 80 percent of state and local workers have pensions, just 50 percent of private-sector workers do.  

Unionized government employees not only want to keep their bloated compensation packages, but their leaders are desperate for more members and more union dues.  That is why public-sector unions have become a fierce lobbying force for higher taxes and more spending across the country.  Organized labor once fought against taxes and regulations that impeded the economic interests of their employers, but now they are in alliance with environmentalists pushing private sector and economy-crippling cap-and-trade legislation, says Carroll. 

Source: Conn Carroll, "Government Unions Win, You Lose," Heritage Foundation, January 25th, 2010 

For text:  


Browse more articles on Economic Issues