NCPA - National Center for Policy Analysis


October 8, 2009

Candor about taxes is rare in Washington, so when House Speaker Nancy Pelosi admits that Democrats may have to impose a huge new tax on the middle class to fund their spending ambitions, believe her, says the Wall Street Journal.

Speaking with PBS's Charlie Rose on Monday, Pelosi mused publicly about the rising possibility of enacting a value-added tax, or VAT, as part of broader tax reform.  "Somewhere along the way, a value-added tax plays into this," she said.  "Of course, we want to take down the health care cost, that's one part of it.  But in the scheme of things, I think it's fair to look at a value-added tax as well."

  • The allure of a VAT for politicians is that it applies to every level of production or service, rakes in piles of money, and is largely hidden from those who ultimately pay it -- namely, consumers.
  • With a $9 trillion 10-year budget deficit, $4 trillion in spending in fiscal 2010 alone, and a $1 trillion (at a minimum) health care entitlement in the wings, Pelosi knows that not even the revenue from the expiration of the lower Bush tax rates in 2011 will cover the bills.
  • Nearly every European country that has passed national health care has also eventually imposed a VAT, and it's foolish to think the United States will be different.

Pelosi is the second prominent Democrat to call for a VAT in recent weeks.  John Podesta, an adviser to President Obama and president of the very liberal Center for American Progress, called in September for a "small and more progressive" VAT.   Pelosi and  Podesta argue a new tax is necessary to address the nation's exploding financial liabilities, as if those liabilities exploded on their own.  Of course, VATs always start "small" and get bigger.  The bills for the Democratic spending blowout are coming due even sooner than advertised, and the middle class will pay, whatever Obama's campaign promises.

Source: Editorial, "Mrs. Pelosi's VAT; The Speaker floats a middle-class tax hike," Wall Street Journal, October 8, 2009.

For text:


Browse more articles on Tax and Spending Issues