NCPA - National Center for Policy Analysis


June 30, 2009

All over the state, parents and students are rallying against proposed budget cuts to Arizona's public colleges and universities.  Instead of focusing ire at legislators, who are literally between a rock and a hard place, there's another avenue these newly minted activists could pursue.  For Arizonans concerned about increasing access to postsecondary education, why not focus on loosening up state regulations that are choking higher education's private sector, asks Nick Dranias of the Goldwater Institute?

Numerous laws make it a crime to open a private postsecondary or vocational school in Arizona without state approval.  These laws result in fewer schools and fewer opportunities for students and educators.

Legislators could embrace academic freedom by deregulating private schooling and let the market work, says Dranias:

  • Arizona pervasively criminalizes entrepreneurs who teach or open a school without government approval.
  • It is a Class 3 misdemeanor to open a private postsecondary school that offers a degree of any kind without approval from the state Board for Private Postsecondary Schooling.
  • Osteopaths and medical doctors cannot teach without a license; private cosmetology and radiologic technology schools cannot legally open their doors without approval from state agencies.

The regulation of nursing schools is a particularly outrageous case in point, says Dranias:

  • Despite the shortage of health care workers in this state and elsewhere, Arizona law makes it a Class 6 felony to open a nursing school without approval from the state Board of Nursing.
  • The risk of jail time for teaching nursing even extends to out-of-state schools that want to offer Arizonans the option of distance learning.

There is no need for these draconian laws, because private postsecondary or vocational schools are self-regulating.  To compete with other schools and qualify for national accreditation, just about every school voluntarily meets minimum educational standards.

Arizona's heavy-handed regulation does nothing to promote quality or prevent fraud.  It only stops the free market from giving students and educators viable alternatives to the taxpayer-funded public university and community college system.  And by fostering an artificial scarcity of educational options, the regulation of private schooling magnifies any pain associated with the loss of public funding for higher education, says Dranias.

Source: Nick Dranias, "Deregulation can help solve education budget crisis," Tucson Citizen, June 30, 2009.

For text:


Browse more articles on Education Issues