LONG-RUN EFFECTS OF UNIONS ON FIRMS

May 18, 2009

A successful effort to unionize a workplace apparently reduces the market value of affected publicly-traded firms, even if there is no immediate change in their operating performance, says the National Bureau of Economic Research (NBER).

In "Long-Run Impacts of Unions on Firms: New Evidence From Financial Markets, 1961-1999,"  co-authors David Lee and Alexandre Mas estimate that the average effect of a union win at a workplace is to decrease the market value of the affected business by at least $40,500 (in $1998) per worker eligible to vote, based on monthly stock prices for 24 months before and after a vote to unionize.  Their simulations suggest that a policy-induced doubling of unionization in the United States would "lead to a 4.3 percent decrease in the equity value of all firms at risk of unionization."

  • The decrease in equity value associated with unionization begins at the time the union wins its election and continues for about 15 months afterward.
  • Calculations of the effects of a union victory suggest that it produces large negative returns of 10 to 14 percent.
  • The authors also find that the effects are quite variable, depending on the degree of support for the union.
  • When unions win elections with a bare majority, there is almost no union effect.
  • But when unions win by a large margin, the effect can be as large as 25 to 40 percent.

The advantage of analyzing the stock market response to unionization is that if the stock market "correctly prices the firm, it should capture the sum of all costs imposed by the union, and effects that might occur many years in the future should be capitalized into the stock market valuation of the firm in the short run."

The authors note that the reduction in equity value represents "a combination of a transfer to workers as well as lost profit due to inefficiencies caused by the union."  Their calculations suggest that if the true union wage effect were 8 percent, this would imply a 2 percent efficiency loss attributable to unions, as priced by the market.

Source: Linda Gorman, "Long-Run Effects of Unions on Firms," NBER Digest, May 2009; based upon: David Lee and Alexandre Mas, "Long-Run Impacts of Unions on Firms: New Evidence from Financial Markets, 1961-1999," National Bureau of Economic Research, Working Paper No. 14709, February 2009.

For text:

http://www.nber.org/digest/may09/w14709.html

 

Browse more articles on Economic Issues