Exporting EnergyCommentary by Bob McTeer
June 24, 2014
Im afraid the phrase "too soon old, too late smart" applies to me. To that should be added "too late informed." Im always discovering new information about topics I thought I knew thoroughly. Take Jerry Lee Lewis, for example. Ive been a lifelong fan, and he is still my go-to guy when I seek nostalgia from You Tube. I dont doze off when he performs solo or does a medley with his cousin Willy Gilley or even Tom Jones. Then the other day I discovered for the first time that Jerry Lee had a beautiful sister, Linda Gail Lewis, that could sing rock and roll with the best of them. Who knew? You Tube has a search feature. I encourage you to take advantage of it.
Another recent discovery that shouldnt have been was the discovery that the U.S. government, sometime in the past when everyone was worried about oil and gas shortages, passed a law forbidding their export. We would keep our own while we asked others to export to us. I learned about this, Im embarrassed to say, only when the question came up recently in connection with fracking and our new-found oil and gas supplies. Believe it or not, many people still think its a good idea to prohibit exports.
I dont know the details, and dont really want to, but I have trouble believing that grown men and women dont see the obvious: that oil and gas, like money, are fungible. They will flow to where they are needed most and where the price reflects that. Cut off one avenue of trade and another, less efficient one, will appear.
Another way to think about it is to recall that there are two ways a country can get goods: to make them domestically, or to import them and pay for them with exports of something else. In other words, the goods can be made or obtained by trade. A prohibition on exports will close the trade option, which would only have been used if it were more efficient. Reducing exports by fiat will reduce imports, although the problem more often is prohibiting imports and thereby reducing exports.
Weve long longed for "energy independence." That desire makes sense so long as we are importing the major portion of our energy. Once we are approaching energy independence, total independence makes no sense. Before total independence is reached, it will surely become more profitable (efficient) to pay for some imports of energy with exports of beans or peaches or something. Comparative advantage generally doesnt lead to complete specialization and attempts to force it will lower our standard of living.
Even Jerry Lee found it advantageous to let his little sister sing occasionally.