|
National defense is a core function of and a primary justification for national
government. An implicit contract exists among a nation's people, its government
and its military. The government promises to provide its people and their interests
with the best defense possible. It promises to provide the military with the
best training and armaments available.
The military promises to do the best job possible to
protect the nation from invasion and to prosecute wars in defense of the country's
interests and ideals. In turn, the people promise to support the military and
provide funds necessary to carry out its designated functions.
Lately, the U.S. government has not been keeping its
end of the bargain, placing the lives of citizens and soldiers alike at risk.
This became especially apparent when the government recently announced a court
settlement under which the Navy would not be allowed to use cutting-edge sonar
technologies to protect the U.S. coast from quiet diesel submarines — like those
used by North Korea .
Some scientists fear the sonar might have caused the
death of beaked whales that beached themselves in the Canary Islands soon after
an international naval exercise last year. Researchers did necropsies on the
whales and found 10 of the 14 dead animals had a condition similar to decompression
sickness or the "bends."
We no longer confront the Soviet Union with nuclear-armed
submarines cruising off our coasts. However, rogue states around the world armed
with conventional submarines could launch missiles killing thousands of people
on the East and West Coasts and in the Gulf of Mexico area absent the use of
various types of sonar now facing restrictions. While there are exemptions to
these restrictions during times of war or heightened threat conditions, these
may be too late since any enemy planning to attack the U.S. is unlikely to warn
us first.
This sonar study's sample was very small. Further doubt
springs from the inconsistency of its findings with other similar studies and
the skepticism of many scientists that rapid ascents cause the bends in whales
that should have evolved mechanisms to avoid decompression.
Even if the findings of this study are nevertheless correct — we
should ask: Isn't the government morally obligated to put the lives and safety
of its citizens and its men and women in uniform ahead of the health of whales?
If not, the world is now a topsy-turvy place, whose leaders lack a moral compass.
Unfortunately, the U.S. Navy is not the only branch of
the armed services impaired by environmental restrictions. The Pentagon has said
federal regulations governing endangered species among other environmental regulations
are the No. 1 obstacle to military training.
The National Center for Public Policy Research has noted
that mechanized units from Fort Irwin in California cannot train in the Mojave
Desert at night because they might run over a desert tortoise — even though nighttime
combat operations are the norm in conflicts like those in Iraq and Afghanistan.
At Fort Lewis , in Washington state, 72 percent of training
land is considered critical habitat for the northern spotted owl, though none
are known to live there. Various federal rules restrict operations at 83 percent
of Fort Hood in Texas .
In addition, at Camp Pendleton , California — the only
West Coast amphibious training base — regulations protecting the tidewater goby
fish and other species have reduced the beach available for Marine Corps amphibious
assault training.
At the Barry M. Goldwater Air Force Range in Arizona
, the Defense Department must ensure before test flights that no endangered Sonoran
pronghorn antelopes living on the base are within firing range of any target
areas. If just one antelope is spotted anywhere nearby, a target is eliminated
from training.
Since the restrictions were put in place in 1997, they
have resulted in cancellation of 40 percent of the live-fire training missions.
As Sen. John McCain, Arizona Republican, put it: "We're faced here with
a choice between the Sonoran pronghorn and conducting a realistic training for
our men and women... in harm's way."
These are hardly isolated cases, since more than 300
plants and animals on the endangered species list are located on military installations.
How many casualties have the U.S. armed forces suffered due to environmental
restrictions on military training? No one knows, but even one is too many.
If the horrific terrorists' assaults of September 11,
2001 , taught us anything, it should be that the world, even after the end of
the Cold War, remains a dangerous place. Accordingly, concerns, however noble,
for endangered species should not be allowed to jeopardize the safety of our
nation and its defenders.
|